In identifying 2021 as the Year of Security Culture, ICAO recognized the most significant factor influencing the effectiveness of security measures applied to protect civil aviation. Culture in an organizational context, put simply, can be defined as ‘the way we do things around here; the keyword being ‘we’ – the people who are responsible for ensuring the security of the travelling public and their colleagues.
Security measures contained within Annex 17 and the associated guidance in the restricted ICAO Aviation Security Manual, Doc 8973, have evolved in-line with the threat to civil aviation. This evolution has seen the continual development of policies, procedures and the technology necessary to mitigate the ever-evolving threat. However, at its core, it is the commitment and diligence of those applying the security measures that are the key driver of effective security.
As an ICAO recognized Aviation Security Training Centre (ASTC), ASTC Doncaster, Redline Assured Security, has had the privilege of delivering the full suite of ICAO Aviation Security Training Packages and Workshops to delegates visiting their National Security Training Centre and overseas, with our Certified Instructors undertaking short term missions on behalf of ICAO Implementation Support and Development Section – Security (ISD-SEC). In our experience, effective security is dependent upon three key components, ‘skill’, ‘will’ and ‘focus’. A weakness in any one of these areas reduces the effectiveness of security, no matter how strong the other components are.
Structured training ensures delegates are equipped with the knowledge, competence and confidence (the skills) to fulfill their duties. In order to be effective, they also require the necessary ‘will’ and ‘focus’. The culture in which they operate must acknowledge that qualification and certification is the start of the journey to excellence, not the endpoint.
The impact of an effective mentoring programme focused on the transference of skills in the training environment into operational practice should not be underestimated and will, delivered well, ensure competence and confidence. However, we have witnessed first-hand security staff who, having proven their knowledge and competence to be at the highest level when under training and the scrutiny of the instructor, subsequently lapse and fail to apply the very same knowledge and competence in the operational environment. Invariably, this is due to a combination of a lack of ‘will’ and ‘focus’.
Their motivation and pride are diminished due to operational factors, i.e, their immediate supervision or organizational leadership do not encourage the same standards, or they lack the resources necessary to focus their attention effectively.
Both ‘will’ and ‘focus’ are crucial to developing a security culture. ‘Will’ can be best defined as the desire to be effective and is influenced significantly by the standards of the organization in which an individual operates. Supervisory and management oversight and engagement are crucial in supporting and motivating people to apply and develop their knowledge and skills. This approach has to be cascaded down from the highest tiers of an organization’s leadership. Leaders must uphold the very same standards they expect from their people, and must ‘walk the walk’. Aviation security managerial training focuses predominantly on roles and responsibilities; however, broader development in the art of supervision and management is essential for those directly responsible for the operational implementation of security if the ‘will’ is to be nurtured and developed within their teams.
‘Focus’ is best maintained through creating the right environment for people to perform, this spans the physical through to the mental. Do they have the necessary equipment, are they rotated through tasks, are they provided with appropriate rest breaks? In short, are they given the best opportunity to apply their skills effectively? Whilst ‘will’ is heavily influenced by an individual’s chain of supervision and management, ‘focus’ is heavily reliant upon the organizational response to security, i.e., the systems, practices and processes designed to enable the effective application of security measures. The ‘organization’ (leadership, managers and supervisors) must have a clear appreciation of the challenges staff face in striving to do their task well, and seek to alleviate and mitigate those as far as reasonably practicable.
Structured training, in accordance with a state’s National Civil Aviation Security Training Programme, is essential to the effective implementation of security. However, it is the organizational attention to ‘skill’, ‘will’ and ‘focus’ that enables individuals to perform effectively, contribute to, and take ownership of, their security responsibilities. It forms the building blocks of a culture where security is everyone’s responsibility.
About the Contributor
Redline Assured Security, ASTC Doncaster, is an internationally acclaimed security consultancy. Acquired by the Air Partner Group in 2019, the company forms part of the Safety & Security Division, which also includes aviation safety experts, Baines Simmons. The Division offers an extensive range of safety and security products and services spanning training, quality assurance, compliance management, consultancy, and innovative software solutions. This combined capability provides clients with all the services and support they need to improve their performance through enhanced capabilities and processes, and increased visibility of their risks and vulnerabilities.